Writes Rachel Harrison, Assistant Librarian
Our latest Book Boffz session introduced a new activity called “Take the Hot Seat.” The Book Boffz took turns to blindly select three discussion cards, each featuring a question linked to reading, books, or libraries. Sitting in the “hot seat,” they shared their responses before inviting the rest of the group to join in, leading to some lively and thought-provoking group discussions.
The questions covered a wide range of ideas. Some were straightforward, such as “Do you usually finish the books you start?” and “Do awards and bestseller lists matter to you?” Others encouraged deeper reflection, including a powerful observation by the 19th-century writer and abolitionist Frederick Douglass: “Once you learn to read, you will be forever free.” This prompted discussion about the value of reading and its ability to transport you to different times and places.
Some questions sparked especially lively debate, with a real mix of opinions across the group. For example, “Would you read a book if you knew it was written by AI?” produced a range of responses: some said they would, others pointed out that it is becoming increasingly difficult to tell, meaning readers might already be engaging with AI-written texts without realising it, while others were clear that they would definitely prefer not to read them at all. Meanwhile, “Are books gendered, or do we just treat them that way?” led to reflections on how society and marketing can shape our perceptions of books and reading. The question of whether books should have age ratings, like films, also prompted discussion, with many suggesting this could feel limiting and expressing appreciation for the more subtle guidance offered by the school library.
One question that surprisingly prompted strong reactions was “How do you feel about sad endings?” Some Book Boffz reflected that reading sad stories at a young age had upset them so much that they now much prefer more uplifting conclusions. Another lively debate centred on whether there is value in keeping a record of the books you read. Opinions were divided: some felt it was wholly unnecessary (“a total waste of time” in fact,) while others described it as a meaningful family tradition and something fascinating to look back on.
One particularly reassuring moment for the library team came when the group was asked, “If libraries disappeared, would it bother you?” The response was an immediate and resounding yes, highlighting just how much our library at Merchant Taylors’ is valued.
The group worked through only a small proportion of the available discussion cards, leaving plenty still to explore. With so many questions to choose from, this is definitely an activity we can return to in future sessions.
Overall, the session was a fantastic reminder that reading is not just about books; it’s about sharing ideas, listening to others, and seeing things from new perspectives.
Book Boffz meet on Fridays after school and is open to all 3rds and U3rds who enjoy books, reading, related activities and of course biscuits!
